When it comes to selecting the right ammunition for self-defense, understanding the key differences between hollow-point and full metal jacket (FMJ) rounds is crucial. Each type has its own advantages and drawbacks, which can significantly impact your self-defense strategy and outcomes.
What Is Hollow-Point Ammunition?
The metal surrounding the cavity of a hollow-point round expands or “mushrooms” out upon impact with flesh or other fluid materials.
Hollow-point ammunition contains a divot in the very tip of the bullet. Upon impact with soft materials — such as flesh — the material fills this cavity and causes the surrounding rim to mushroom out. The standard acceptable expansion is 1.7 times the original diameter of the projectile. So a .45 ACP hollow-point (with an original diameter of 0.451 inches) should expand to at least 0.7667 inches. Some rounds expand to nearly twice the original size, depending on the design and composition of the projectile and the muzzle velocity when it impacts the target.
Why Would Someone Choose Hollow-Point Ammo?
The expansion of a hollow-point bullet generates two main effects.
- A larger diameter bullet produces a wider wound channel. Increased blood loss leads to a faster drop in the target’s blood pressure — hopefully ending the threat more quickly. Remember, the point of a legal self-defense shooting is to stop the threat as quickly as possible.
- The loss of velocity decreases the chance of over-penetration. When a hollow-point bullet mushrooms, it expends considerable forward momentum. This helps to keep the round from continuing through the target and potentially hitting an unintentional victim in the background.
This Jacketed Hollow-Point (JHP) round involves a copper jacket over a lead core. Notice the hollow cavity in the lead at the tip of the bullet and the serrations at the top of the copper jacket.
What Are the Downsides of Hollow-Point Ammo?
The limited penetration mentioned above could fail to produce a wound serious enough to stop an attacker. Barriers such as thick winter clothing or moderate cover would exacerbate this problem. Alternatively, it is possible for clothing or other materials to get caught up in the hollow tip of the bullet, impeding expansion.
The FBI prescribes a minimum of 12 inches and a maximum of 18 inches as the optimal depth for bullet penetration in a human target. Once again, muzzle velocity greatly impacts not only how well a bullet expands, but the depth to which it will penetrate.
Will Your Gun Take Hollow Points?
Some rifles and pistols, especially semi-automatics, may have trouble feeding hollow-point rounds. While most modern handguns are designed to accept a wide variety of ammunition, hollow-points may cause some to misfeed or jam. Be sure to test specific brands in your concealed carry gun — especially if it’s the firearm you intend to carry every day. A crucial self-defense moment is no time to discover that your carry gun doesn’t like to fire hollow points.
The Legal Issue of Hollow Points
While most police departments throughout the country issue hollow-point ammo to officers (to cut down on that pesky overpenetration described above), some states have made it illegal for use by civilians. As we often state on this blog, be sure to know your local laws regarding firearms and ammunition.
What Is Full Metal Jacket (FMJ) Ammo?
In contrast, full metal jacket (FMJ) ammunition features a bullet with no exposed lead on the nose or sides. FMJ rounds are commonly used for training purposes due to their affordability and reliability in semi-automatic firearms. However, they are not typically recommended for self-defense scenarios.
Find Defensive Shooting Classes
One of the main drawbacks of FMJ ammunition is its tendency to over-penetrate. Unlike hollow-points, which expand upon impact and transfer all of their energy to the target, FMJ rounds may pass through the intended target and continue traveling, posing a risk to bystanders or property beyond the initial point of impact. This phenomenon is often likened to a pencil punching a hole through a target but then persisting in its trajectory.
Unless mandated by law, opting for FMJ ammunition for self-defense carries significant considerations. Perfect target isolation and awareness of what lies beyond the target are essential when using FMJ rounds to minimize the risk of unintended consequences.
Hollow-Point vs. FMJ: Which is Better for Self-Defense?
When debating between hollow-point and FMJ ammunition for self-defense, the choice largely depends on your priorities, local regulations, and individual circumstances. Here’s a breakdown of the key factors to consider:
Stopping Power: Hollow-point rounds are designed to maximize stopping power by expanding upon impact, creating larger wound channels and increasing the likelihood of incapacitating a threat quickly. FMJ rounds, on the other hand, may lack the same stopping power due to their tendency to over-penetrate without expanding.
Overpenetration Risk: Hollow-point ammunition significantly reduces the risk of overpenetration compared to FMJ rounds. This makes hollow-points a safer choice for self-defense scenarios where minimizing collateral damage is paramount.
Legal Considerations: While hollow-point ammunition is preferred for self-defense purposes in most cases, it’s essential to familiarize yourself with local laws and regulations. Some states, such as New Jersey, have restrictions on the use of hollow-points, necessitating the use of FMJ ammunition for concealed carry.
Ammo Compatibility: Another aspect to consider is the compatibility of your chosen ammunition with your firearm. Ensure that your firearm is reliable with the selected hollow-point or FMJ rounds through testing and practice sessions.
Remember, your choice of ammunition for self-defense should prioritize safety, effectiveness and compliance with applicable laws. With understanding the differences between hollow-point and FMJ rounds and making an informed decision, you can enhance your preparedness and confidence in defending yourself and your loved ones responsibly.
