When it comes to self-defense, you may not always be able to rely on a loaded gun as an effective response to a lethal threat. The psychological and physiological complexities involved in using lethal force, as highlighted by military historian Brigadier S.L.A. Marshall, challenge this notion. Marshall’s insights, recorded in his book Men Against Fire, revealed that even well-trained soldiers in World War II exhibited reluctance to shoot at the enemy, raising questions about the automatic response to a lethal attack.
Marshall’s findings, supported by later research by Lt. Col. Dave Grossman in his book On Killing, shed light on the innate aversion humans have to killing their own kind. Societal, cultural, moral and religious norms contribute to this aversion, creating a reluctance to use lethal force even in life-threatening situations.
Recognizing the multifaceted nature of employing lethal force, law enforcement agencies have developed training scenarios and adopted the 21-foot rule. This rule underscores the imperative for officers to swiftly react to an impending threat within close quarters, underscoring the intricate challenges associated with identifying and responding to a potentially lethal attack effectively.
Non-Lethal and Less-Lethal Self-Defense Options
For civilians, the decision to use lethal force is a personal and legal challenge. Firearms are powerful tools for self-defense, but not everyone is comfortable using them or can carry them in all situations. In light of this, it’s crucial to explore non-lethal and less-lethal self-defense options that align with legal and personal considerations.
It’s essential to recognize the distinction between “less-lethal” and “non-lethal” when evaluating self-defense tools. While the term “non-lethal” is commonly used, it can be misleading. In reality, all weapons, regardless of their intended level of force, have the potential to be lethal under certain circumstances. Therefore, the more accurate terminology is “less-lethal,” emphasizing that these tools are designed to minimize the likelihood of causing lethal harm rather than completely eliminating it.
Understanding this distinction underscores the importance of treating all self-defense tools with utmost respect and caution. Even those categorized as “less-lethal” should be wielded responsibly, considering their potential impact. It emphasizes the need for individuals to be well-informed about the proper use of force, ensuring that the chosen self-defense tools are employed judiciously and in accordance with legal guidelines. By acknowledging the inherent potential for lethality in any self-defense situation, individuals can make informed decisions that prioritize safety and legality.
Pepper Spray as Non-Lethal Self-Defense
Pepper spray as a non-lethal alternative for self-defense is designed to temporarily incapacitate an attacker. The spray is made from oleoresin capsicum, which irritates the eyes, causing intense pain and making it difficult to see. Pepper spray can also cause those exposed to it to produce tremendous amounts of mucus and tears. Exposure may make the person think he or she is having difficulty breathing. These effects often allow the user to escape an attack. The primary advantage of carrying pepper spray is that it can be used from a distance, making it a safer option. On the downside, once pepper spray is deployed, others, including the user, can fall victim to indirect exposure. While the effects of indirect exposure are not as intense as a direct spray to the face, they can be painful. Any use of pepper spray indoors will very likely clear the room. Use of pepper spray in a large crowd may cause a stampede as people try to get away from the stuff.
The PepperBall Tactical Compact Pistol (TCP) is a civilian pistol-style launcher that is exactly the same as the original law enforcement model (also called TCP). It is the size of a large pistol and weighs 1.7 pounds. It comes with two six-round magazines. Additional original round or long-range VXR projectiles must be purchased separately. The refill packs contain practice and live projectiles. The PepperBall TCP is simple to operate and by far PepperBall’s most powerful civilian launcher, propelling round or conical VXR PepperBall projectiles up to 150 feet.
Tasers or Stun Guns
Taser is the brand name of an electroshock weapon designed to incapacitate an attacker by sending a jolt of electricity through the body. Electronic stun guns are often mistakenly called Tasers, but the two devices work on completely different principles. The primary difference between a Taser and a stun gun is the distance at which they can be used. Stun guns only work at contact distance. The electrodes must be held in place against an attacker. Tasers can be deployed from up to 25 feet away, but if both probes do not sink into the attacker’s flesh, the effect is minimal at best. Tasers are also difficult to reload and redeploy if you miss your target.
Batons: A Less-Than-Lethal Weapon
A baton is a versatile weapon that can be used for both defensive and offensive purposes. They come in various lengths and can be made from materials such as wood or metal. The primary advantage of batons is that they can provide enough force to stop an attacker without causing permanent damage. However, a baton as a primary self-defense tool can be difficult to carry and bulky. Expandable metal batons are smaller but still by no means easy to carry. Using a baton also requires that you be within arm’s reach of your attacker. This close proximity increases the chances you could be grabbed, struck or kicked. Effective defense with a baton also requires some training and at least a moderate level of strength and mobility.
A Kubaton is a small metal or plastic device that is typically attached to a keychain and has a pointed end that can be used to strike an assailant in the event of an attack. In addition to being used as a weapon, Kubatons can also be used for breaking glass or even as an aid in rescue situations. Small and unobtrusive, the Kubaton is easy to carry and can be quick to deploy if you’re using situational awareness and keep it in your hand when you fear an attack. It can enhance the power and pain behind your defensive strikes. But, like with the baton, the use of a Kubaton requires you be very close to your attacker, meaning you will likely be in the attacker’s grasp when you deploy this tool. With even a basic level of training, a Kubaton can be effective in causing the attacker enough pain to break contact, giving you a chance to escape.
Knives for Self-Defense
While knives may not be for everyone, they can be an effective tool for self-defense in certain situations. Knives come in various shapes, sizes and styles, all of which can be used to stop an attacker. It is important to remember that knives require training to be used safely and effectively. This is especially true of folding knives (the most popular knives sold today), which can be difficult and slow to open when under stress. On the plus side, when you are holding and using a knife for self-defense, it can be very difficult for someone to take the knife away from you without being cut. Conversely, you must be careful when using a knife not to cut yourself. Like the other defensive tools mentioned above you must be very close to your attacker to use a knife effectively. In a defensive situation, proximity means danger. State and local knife laws are a patchwork of differing definitions and requirements. A knife that may be legal in one locale may not be legal in another.
Choosing the Right Less-Lethal Option for You
When selecting a non-lethal or less-lethal weapon, consider factors like legal restrictions, personal comfort and training requirements. While these alternatives may not replace the effectiveness of a loaded firearm, they provide viable options for situations where deadly force is not the preferred choice.
Navigating the complexities of self-defense involves understanding the psychological and legal aspects of using force. Non-lethal and less-lethal self-defense options offer valuable alternatives, allowing individuals to protect themselves in situations where firearms may not be suitable. As you explore these options, prioritize safety, legality and proper training to make informed choices that align with your personal values and circumstances.
This article is a compilation of previous blog posts authored by Kevin Michalowski, Ed Combs, Scott W. Wagner, Bruce N. Eimer and Rick Baratta.