I started my law enforcement career some 46 years ago as a reserve (also known as auxiliary) deputy sheriff in Licking County, Ohio. I was equipped with my own personally purchased, brand-new blued Smith & Wesson Model 19 .357 Magnum revolver with a 4-inch barrel, a hand-me-down uniform and a hand-me-down gun belt.
The gun belt had been kept in decent shape and included a leather holster. Spare ammunition could be carried in a cowboy-style belt holder with 12 loops for .38 Special or .357 Magnum cartridges. We were restricted to .38 Special loads and had to provide our own duty ammunition.
The fastest way to reload from that belt holder was to pull two cartridges at a time and load them into the revolver’s cylinder, repeating the process until the six-shooter was topped off.
Fortunately, a better way to reload an empty double-action revolver was becoming popular: the cylindrical revolver speedloader.
After years of using conventional speedloaders, I thought 5 Star Firearms was already at the top of its game. Then the company introduced a design I never would have dreamed of: the new DC Series of speedloaders.
How 5 Star Speedloaders Compare With Traditional Designs
HKS was the first brand of speedloader I used with a duty revolver. In fact, HKS was the brand I used for the 14 years I carried a revolver as my primary duty handgun.
It held six rounds in a plastic cylinder that was the diameter of the revolver’s cylinder. An aluminum knob at the top turned clockwise to release the cartridges into the chambers.
5 Star makes a similar twist-knob speedloader, made from polished aluminum. I favor the 5 Star loaders over the original HKS design for a couple of reasons.
First, the shiny aluminum finish makes them easier to locate if they’re dropped in the dark (unless you choose one of the darker anodized colors).
Second, 5 Star’s knob turns counterclockwise to release the ammunition, rather than clockwise like the HKS. I’ve always considered that an improvement because the left-hand twist naturally helps move the loader clear of the handgun after releasing the rounds.
5 Star’s traditional loaders are finely machined and reliable, and they seem to be popular enough. But now 5 Star has come up with an innovative new speedloader design that I never would have imagined.
What Is the 5 Star DC Series Speedloader?

The 5 Star DC Series includes 11 models designed for a wide range of revolvers, including models chambered in .38 Special, .357 Magnum, .44 Magnum, .45 Colt and larger calibers.
The lineup also included options for revolvers such as the Taurus Judge and Smith & Wesson .500 models. Since I didn’t have any of those truly big bruiser hand cannons in my safe for testing, I requested two loaders:
- J2: Designed for five-shot Smith & Wesson .38 Special/.357 Magnum revolvers.
- J5: A five-shot .44/.45 loader I wanted to try with the Charter Arms Classic Bulldog .44 Special revolver I’d recently tested.
Side-Mounted Release Button
The DC Series looks different from other speedloaders on the market. Its most noticeable difference is replacing the traditional twist-to-release knob with a flat, spring-loaded aluminum button that protrudes from the side of the loader like a miniature diving board.
The exposed end has a slight curve that comfortably accommodates pressure from the tip of your thumb.
You’ll also notice a bright brass-colored inset button on top of the loader. Ignore that. It’s actually a retainer that holds the release mechanism in place and has no operational function.
How the Cartridge-Retention System Works
Pressing the flat button on the side of the speedloader moves the internal retention mechanism, allowing users to drop in live rounds.
Once the cartridge rims are positioned correctly, releasing the button locks the cartridges in place. When it’s time to reload the revolver, pressing the button again releases the cartridges into the cylinder.
It’s a clever arrangement that eliminates the twisting motion required by conventional knob-style loaders.
How to Use the 5 Star DC Series Speedloader
Because the DC Series operates differently from traditional speedloaders, I spent some time figuring out the most comfortable way to use it.
1. Position the Revolver and Speedloader
With the revolver’s cylinder open and empty, orient the firearm downward.
Hold the speedloader with your strong-hand thumb positioned in the curve of the release button. Your index, middle and ring fingers can rest in the corresponding grooves around the loader’s body.
2. Align the Cartridges with the Cylinder
With your thumb at approximately the 6 o’clock position relative to the open cylinder, align two bullet noses with their corresponding chambers.
As those rounds enter the cylinder, the remaining cartridges should line up with the other chambers.
If you’re having to force the rounds into place, something isn’t aligned properly.
I’ve found that speedloading generally works best with round-nose practice ammunition or round-nose hollow points. Semi-wadcutter and wadcutter bullets are more difficult to load with just about any type of speedloader.
Rounded bullets should glide into the chambers like a torpedo entering the tube of a World War II submarine. Heavier bullets (110+ grains) also receive a little more assistance from gravity than some of the ultralight, high-velocity loads.
3. Press the Button to Release the Cartridges
Once all the cartridges are aligned with their respective chambers, press the release button fully with your thumb.
The cartridges are released together into the cylinder.
I found that the thumb-operated approach was more comfortable than trying to activate the button with my index finger.
Left-handed shooters can use the same general approach with the loader in the left hand, operating the button with the left thumb.
After releasing the ammunition, the empty loader can be discarded from the hand so the shooter can complete the reload.
4. Reload the Speedloader
My wife, who is always intrigued by mechanical things even though she can’t see, figured out the simplest way to reload the loader itself.
Set the loader on a tabletop or other flat surface with its cartridge openings facing upward.
Place the cartridge bases into the loader, then press and release the side button to lock the rounds in place.
Once they’re locked in place, you can pick up the loaded speedloader. It’s pretty slick.

A Manufacturer Demonstration Would Help
Before finding a loading demonstration on YouTube, I checked 5 Star’s website to see whether it included a video showing how to operate the DC Series. Unfortunately, I didn’t find one.
I’d like to see 5 Star provide an instructional video for this design because it differs so much from the other speedloaders on the market.
5 Star DC Series Speedloader Compatibility
An important consideration with any revolver speedloader is whether it clears the handgun’s grips. Even a loader designed for the correct caliber and cylinder capacity may encounter interference from the grip panels.
I discovered this while trying the new 5 Star loaders with two different revolvers.
Charter Arms Classic Bulldog .44 Special
I requested the J5 .44/.45 loader for the Charter Arms Classic Bulldog, a five-shot .44 Special revolver I’d reviewed the previous week.
The new Classic Bulldog retains much of the original revolver’s design, although the finish and trigger are considerably improved. It also wears excellent walnut grips similar to those on the original 1973 Bulldog.
Unfortunately, those grips created a clearance problem. The grip panel isn’t sufficiently relieved to provide the space needed for the speedloader.
This isn’t a problem with the J5 loader from the DC series. It’s a matter of grip thickness and clearance. Other Charter Arms Bulldog models have grips designed to accommodate speedloaders, and replacement grips are available for the Classic.
Smith & Wesson Model 638 Bodyguard
However, the J2 loader worked perfectly with my Smith & Wesson Model 638 Bodyguard.
My Model 638 is equipped with a set of Hogue laser grips that are, sadly, no longer in production. Fortunately, those grips remain below the cylinder’s reloading area, leaving sufficient clearance for the J2 five-shot .38 Special/.357 Magnum loader.
The cartridges fed smoothly into the cylinder and released easily. And the side-mounted release button helped stabilize the loader against the revolver’s grip frame.
Whether you’re right-handed or left-handed, that additional point of contace helps reduce fumbling.
The Biggest Advantage: Consistent Reloading
After spending time practicing reloads and live fire with the DC Series, I came away convinced that its biggest advantage is consistency.
With a conventional twist-knob loader, you’re turning a knob to release the cartridges. With the DC Series, you have a clearly defined point for your thumb every time.
The button helped me orient the loader against the revolver, and I wasn’t fumbling around trying to find the release. You always have an index point.
The DC Series isn’t simply a different way of releasing ammunition. For me, its greatest benefit is the repeatable hand positioning it encourages.
Why a Clean Revolver Matters for Speedloader Performance
There’s another consideration that applies to every revolver speedloader, regardless of design.
A dirty revolver can make reloading more difficult.
The tolerances between the cartridges and the cylinder chambers are pretty close. Powder residue can interfere with smooth cartridge insertion.
We used to tell new police recruits, “A clean gun is a happy gun.” That’s true of all firearms, but it’s particularly important with manually operated revolvers.
Even a well-designed speedloader can’t compensate for chambers that have become difficult to load because of fouling.
5 Star DC Series Speedloader Price and Accessories
The DC Series costs more than many polymer-bodied speedloaders. Given the excellent quality of manufacturing, these should last just as long as 5 Star’s traditional knob-release speedloaders.
At the time of my review, 5 Star listed the following prices:
| Product | Listed price |
| DC Series | $44.95 |
| Traditional knob-style | $24.95 – $39.95 |
5 Star also offers belt carriers, aluminum block stands and range kits for its speedloader models.
The company’s broader speedloader lineup includes options for revolvers chambered in cartridges ranging from .22 LR to larger calibers such as .460, .480 and .500.
As with any speedloader, be sure to select the model intended for your specific revolver and check grip clearance.
Final Verdict: Is the 5 Star DC Series Speedloader Worth It?
The 5 Star DC Series is an innovation that revolver shooters could easily overlook … but shouldn’t. I would have loved to carry them on duty back in the revolver days.
What impressed me most wasn’t simply the side-mounted release button. It was the consistency the design brought to the reloading process. Once I became comfortable operating the button with my thumb, I had a repeatable index point that made the loader easier to position.
If you’re looking for a fast, effective reloader that helps you orient it consistently, even in the dark, check out 5 Star’s DC Series as well as its traditional knob-style loaders.
You won’t be disappointed.
Source:
5 Star Firearms: 5StarSirearms.com










